New Haven Pizza Place logo

Check Our Menu!

This is our must-try list that has everyone talking

Order Now
Stuffed Bread Sampler

Stuffed Bread Sampler

Can't decide on just one bread? Try them all, the sampler includes: spinach and sausage, pepperoni and mozz & chicken parmesan!

Add Item

Wood-fired Pizza

Wood-fired Pizza

Craving authentic wood-fired pizza in Milford? Visit New Haven Pizza Place at 1377 New Haven Ave for crispy thin crusts, rich tomato sauce, and melty cheese—made fresh daily. Dine in, take out, or order local delivery right here in Connecticut.

Start Your Order

Customer Reviews

Check out our most recent reviews!

Have been here over 10x's I am a huge Pizza lover and this place by far has the most amazing pies! Jazz who is the best bartender in the biz had the cook make me my custom "DonEdo" Steak and cheese with peppers and onion pie and it was out of this world!! Its my go to pizza resturant in Milford, come down Monday ... nights, ask Jazz for the pie and have some cocktails and share laughs and stories. Read More

It was my fiancé and my first time there Jasmine was our bartender, she was absolutely great. We loved talking to her. Our drinks were amazing and so was the food. We made sure that we came back just to see her!

We had our daughter’s 4th birthday party here! It was an amazing experience from the very begining inquiring about renting the room to the clean up from the party. We were able to rent the room, access to the bar, and have plenty of room for family. The pizza as always was incredible! The server we had was so ... friendly and checked in on us multiple times the bartender was so attentive and quick refilling our drinks. 10 out of 10!!!! Read More

Visit Us!

Dine in available.