New Haven Pizza Place

Tina Arango

We had our daughter’s 4th birthday party here! It was an amazing experience from the very begining inquiring about renting the room to the clean up from the party. We were able to rent the room, access to the bar, and have plenty of room for family. The pizza as always was incredible! The server we had was so ... friendly and checked in on us multiple times the bartender was so attentive and quick refilling our drinks. 10 out of 10!!!! Read More

Matthew Ordazzo

Went to my nephews first birthday this past Thursday night. Found out my sister in law was catering the party with New Haven Pizza place pizza. Pizza was amazing! Great taste, quality, and it’s not a heavy pie. Owners are great, foods great. 10/10 everything’s great!

Ken

Top 3 of the best pizza crusts i ever had. Really good pizza. The crust was crispy and chewy and smokey..... Perfect! Nice big bar.

Jim Cozad

In town for business. We were recommended by the locals to give this place a try. Unsuspecting restaurant in a strip mall but the food was great. Pizza is wood fired and thin crust. The meats and cheeses used have a bunch of flavor. Sausage and peppers parmesan was delicious. Even the homemade cracked pepper ... ranch dressing was really good. To top it off, the cannoli's and tiramisu were a great finish to the meal. The only really small complaint is that they seemed understaffed. Our waitress was pleasant, took care of us and kept apologizing for our waits. We could all see how hard she was working so it wasn't a big deal. Read More

Marc Sacco

Eggplant parmesan was excellent. The side salad was good and the garlic bread was okay. The Tribus Benji (IPA) was much better than I expected and the to-go order of tiramisu I got was excellent. Service was just ok (didn't receive an ordered drink) for not being very busy on a Sunday but the barroom atmosphere was ... solid. Highly recommend for the great food! Read More

Tom H

This in my opinion the best New Haven style ahbeetz outside of Wooster street that I have tried. Great flavor perfect amount of char. Best pie in Milford… ties with Papas in my opinion. Excellent prices on dinners and grinders too , their website does not have the full menu showing dinners but the actual menu has ... many choices I almost forgot the sweet chili Thai wings were great, well cooked and not skimpy…7 wings for 8 bucks I think Read More

William Finnegan

Sauce has flavor. Char just the way I like it. Nice little spot

Stephanie Simko

LOVE this spot. Awesome food, good cocktails, great service. Highly recommend the fresh tomato pizza, arancini, and tiramisu. Trivia on Tuesday’s as well!